Supplement Quality Scorecard — Hometown Health
Interactive Tool — Hometown Health

Supplement Quality Scorecard

Not all protein supplements are created equal. Use this tool to evaluate any product against 15 evidence-based quality criteria and get an instant quality rating.

How scoring works:
Green criteria add +2 pts each (max 20)
Red flags subtract −2 pts each
Score range: 0–20
How to use this tool
01

Have your supplement label or product page open so you can check it as you go.

02

Type the product name so your verdict is personalized.

03

Click each card that applies — green for good traits, red to flag concerns.

04

Your score, rating, and verdict update in real time as you check boxes.


Step 1 Name the supplement you're evaluating

Optional — personalizes your verdict.

✓ Quality indicators
+2 pts each · max 20 pts
✗ Red flags
−2 pts each
Score
0 / 20
Quality rating
Red flags 0
0 — Not Recommended 10 — Fair 20 — Excellent
Check off criteria above to generate your quality verdict.

Quick reference — what each criterion means

Understanding the Scorecard